Macs vs PC’s — Pros and Cons

A number of readers have been asking me for recommendations on buying a new computer. Well, the first decision is whether to buy a PC or a Macintosh.

I used to recommend Windows computers for beginners because they have historically comprised 95% of what the world is using. Furthermore, they had always cost less than a similarly equipped Mac. But things have changed to where I can no longer recommend one over the other, but can only list some pros and cons for a buyer's consideration.

A pro for the Mac is that it that it comes with one relatively easy-to-learn operating system, whereas Windows buyers must decide which of seven Vista versions to buy. Beyond this, none of the Vista versions have been the huge success they were expected to be and many PC buyers have opted to return to Windows XP.

For those who would like the best of both worlds, Windows (XP or Vista) can be installed on a Mac, along with dual-booting capabilities. Conversely, no Mac OS can be installed on any Windows machine. Windows users, however, can configure their PCs to have dual-booting between Vista and XP.

Another pro for Mac operating systems is that, historically, they have never been the target of viruses. Many industry observers argue that this is because virus villains have had no interest in the Mac's relatively small customer base, but worry that this may be changing with the Mac's continuing upward sales numbers. Some even claim they have already found a Mac virus in the wild.

A pro for Windows is the fact that its large customer base has always meant it was easy for newbies to find other users to help them get started. Windows user groups abound, but Mac computer clubs tend to be few and far between.

As for specialties, Windows machines have always been the choice of gamers, while Macs have historically been the preference of those who create and edit images and videos. As for business, tons of applications have been written for Windows PCs, while relatively few businesses have Macs in their offices.

In any case, both Mac and Windows versions of Microsoft Office exist — at traditionally high prices. However the free OpenOffice.org suite is also available for both platforms and is MSOffice-compatible.

This is in response to your recent column Macs vs PC’s - Pros and Cons, and our telephone conversation earlier today.

I have a PC running Windows XP Professional SP2 and a Mac running OS 10.4.9. With regard to using the internet, I have found that in my situation where I use dial-up, and have poor telephone lines resulting in 28,800 as the best speed I can get, the Windows system is better. Here is why: In Internet Explorer you can go to Tools>Internet Options>Temporary Internet Files>Settings, and under Check for Newer Versions of Stored Pages, you can select Never. This way Internet Explorer does not reload previously browsed files each time they are revisited. In my situation this makes using the Internet viable. This flexibility is not available on the Mac platform. My Mac has Safari, Firefox, and Internet Explorer 5.2 (the last version made for Mac) and none offer the option to not check for newer version of stored pages, thus making the Mac nearly useless for me on the Internet.

A second shortcoming on Mac is the inability to customize folders vied as thumbnails. In Windows you can open a folder, right click, select Customize this Folder, Choose Picture, and select any picture you want to appear when you display the folder as a thumbnail. That means you can also use Windows Paint to create any color, design, or text and save the file and then have it appear on the folder. This is a wonderful feature, and I am surprised that this feature is not available on the Mac.

I read with interest your piece on whether to choose a Mac or PC when buying a new computer. Thank you for taking a balanced approach to this often emotional (quasi-religious?) argument. As the president of the Oceanside Macintosh User Group (OMUG, www.omug.net) I wanted to take a moment to tell you about our group and its programs. OMUG has been around for many years, serving all of north San Diego County. We hold our regular meetings on the last Wednesday of every month.

We do question and answer sessions and product demonstrations, and then have a formal presentation on a different topic each month. At our last meeting we had noted podcaster Adam Christianson speak to our members about podcasting, relevant technology, and how to find and subscribe to podcasts of interest. In addition to our general meetings, we have special interest groups (SIGs) that meet each month, including a Beyond The Basics group that explores software like iLife in depth, a MacEd class, and a Basic SIG where members and visitors can ask questions and get technical support for anything having to do with their Macintosh. Membership is $25 a year, and visitors are welcome at all of our meetings and events.

In addition to our group, there is also a similar organization in San Diego -SDMUG. We Mac users may not be as numerous as our Windows-using brethren, but we are organized, supportive, and friendly.: )

I would also like to let your readers know that Mac users do have local resources. Here's a link to the list of official groups in California: http://appleusergroups.com/ locator/find/locate.cgi?state=CA